AI Strategy3 min read

You're Invisible to AI

Why SEO Rankings Don't Equal AI Recommendations

LA

The LocalAICheck Team

January 2026

SEO vs AI comparison

Here's a quick experiment. Open ChatGPT and ask: "What's the best [your service] in [your city]?"

Did your business come up? If you don't know, that's a problem. If the answer is no, that's a bigger problem.

The Assumption That's Costing You Customers

Most business owners we talk to assume the same thing: "If I rank well on Google, customers can find me."

A few years ago, that was true. Today? It's increasingly wrong.

57% of consumers now use AI-powered search to find local services. Meanwhile, traditional SEO traffic has declined 22% since AI adoption accelerated. Here's the thing though - that traffic isn't just disappearing. It's being redirected to the businesses that AI decides to recommend.

SEO and AI Play by Different Rules

Think of it like two different games with two different rulebooks. What wins in one doesn't necessarily win in the other.

Traditional SEO

  • Keyword stuffing and optimization
  • Backlink quantity
  • Page speed and technical factors
  • Shows 10+ results - room for everyone

AI Recommendations

  • Entity clarity and understanding
  • Review sentiment (what people actually say)
  • Authority signals from trusted sources
  • Picks 3-5 businesses - winner takes most

See the difference? Google gives you a list of options. AI gives you a recommendation. One is a library, the other is a trusted friend telling you exactly where to go.

How AI Actually Decides Who to Recommend

AI doesn't rank - it selects based on confidence. Here's what it's looking for:

  1. Entity Clarity: Does AI actually understand what you do and where you do it? (Sounds simple, but most businesses fail here)
  2. Authority: Are you mentioned on platforms AI considers trustworthy?
  3. Sentiment: Not just star ratings - what do your reviews actually say about the experience?
  4. Consistency: Is your information the same across the web, or is AI seeing conflicting signals?

The Window Won't Stay Open Forever

Here's what makes this moment interesting: most businesses aren't thinking about AI visibility yet. That's exactly why you should be.

AI visibility compounds over time. The businesses that establish strong presence now are building authority that becomes increasingly difficult for competitors to displace later.

ChatGPT click-through rates tripled between March and June 2025. People aren't just asking AI for information anymore - they're taking action on those recommendations.

Three Things You Can Do Right Now

1

Test your AI presence yourself

Ask ChatGPT and Perplexity for recommendations in your category. See what comes up. Takes 5 minutes and you'll learn a lot.

2

Get a proper assessment

Manual testing only shows you part of the picture. Tools that systematically analyze your presence reveal the full story.

3

Act on what you learn

Once you know where you stand, focus your efforts on the signals that actually matter for AI visibility.

Finding out how AI sees your business isn't optional anymore. It's just good business sense.

Check Your AI Visibility

Ready to check your AI visibility?

See how AI assistants like ChatGPT and Perplexity see your business.

Check Your Visibility Free